Syria, Iraq…Is Pakistan Next?

Kashmir

The civil war in Syria has quickly spilled over into Iraq, a strategy that has resulted in the country losing control of its borders. While military targets anti-Pakistan militants in Zarb-i-Azb operations, some have started to question whether any success will be undermined once Pakistanis fighting with ISIS return home. While the return of Pakistani jihadis from fighting in foreign wars is certainly a threat, there is another more immediate danger. Just as global jihadi groups hijacked Afghan, Syrian, and Iraqi, they have now set their sights on Kashmir.

Continue reading

How ISIS Could Undermine Zarb-i-Azb

ISIS militants in Iraq

At first glance, fighting in Iraq and Zarb-i-Azb seem to be completely unrelated. Iraqis are fighting over control over their own country, and Army is fighting to retain control of ours. What is being missed however is an important connection that could undermine any success Army sees from operations in North Waziristan. It is a threat that we would be very mistaken to ignore.

Continue reading

Slouching Towards Mosul

Pakistani Shia Muslims shout slogans to protest against the bombing which killed 90 people, in Quetta on February 18, 2013

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.”

–William Butler Yeats

Chief Justice of Pakistan Tassaduq Hussain Jillani has ordered that ‘those responsible for religious hate speech on social media must be brought to justice and children who face harassment at their schools because of their religious beliefs should also be protected’. The Chief Justice further recommended the creation of a a national council to overlook the protection of minorities. It is welcome news, but there’s a long way to travel between ‘saying’ and ‘doing’, and one worries that the esteemed Justice’s orders may be a case of ‘too little, too late…’

Continue reading

Is Iraq a glimpse of our future?

Iraq sectarian violence 2013With 2014 less than six months away and the American withdrawal from Afghanistan along with it, many are wondering what is in store. One place we might find a clue is Iraq. After all, this is the location of the most recent American invasion, occupation, and withdrawal and, as with Afghanistan many blamed the violence on the American occupation. It has been two years since President Obama withdrew American forces from Iraq, so what does the country look like now?

Continue reading

Militants Divide & Conquer Strategy

The headlines have become so commonplace that sometimes they go unnoticed. “Shrine attack kills 41”. “Suicide bomber attacks Sufi shrine”. “Deadly attack on religious procession”. “Suicide attack targets Shia marchers”. Innocent Pakistanis being killed by extremist militants allegedly because they are practising some religious acts that the extremists do not approve or according to some it is because of drone attacks or some other event that has resulted in retaliation. Actually, both of these are incorrect. These attacks are part of a carefully crafted strategy to weaken Pakistan internally by creating divisions that can be exploited to undermine the cohesiveness of the state.

This is the same strategy that was used by Abu al-Zarqawi against the people of Iraq. Zarqawi’s evil idea was to commit acts of terror against religious sects so that the people would become divided on sectarian lines.

The targeting of sacred sites was condemned by Jalal Talabani, Iraq’s Kurdish President, as a deliberate attempt to foment sectarian unrest as talks continue to form a functioning coalition government.

“We are facing a major conspiracy that is targeting Iraq’s unity,” Mr Talabani said. “This new ugly crime comes as a warning that there is a conspiracy against the Iraqi people to spark a war among brothers. We should all stand hand-in-hand to prevent the danger of a civil war.”

According to former ambassador and foreign secretary of Pakistan Tanvir Ahmad Khan this same al Qaeda strategy is being used by TTP and other militant groups as a strategy to undermine the state and divide the people against each other by creating fear, suspicion, and resentment among the masses.

The insurgents have shown great ingenuity in opening new fronts and in developing new tactics to exacerbate and exploit differences. One of the relatively new frontlines is the series of attacks on Sufi shrines, a tactic with precedents in Iraq, Afghanistan and other Muslim countries. The South Asian Muslim shrines always attract large crowds of festive devotees on special occasions, and in Pakistan’s case, the attacks have led to horrific loss of life. The latest suicide bombing of a Sufi shrine in Central Punjab on April 4 took over 50 lives.

It should also be noted that these attacks have nothing to do with drone attacks. Whether or not drone attacks are counterproductive as leaders from all political parties have said, we must not assign everything to the same root cause. Ending or limiting drone attacks may have some positive effects, but it will not end terrorism once and for all. That is because these attacks against shrines are not retaliation for drones – no shrine is responsible for launching drone strikes – actually they are a calculated attack meant to weaken Pakistani national cultural identity.

Pakistan is dotted with shrines. Doctrinal arguments apart, they bring comfort to millions and their cultural ethos binds communities, usually cutting across the Shiite-Sunnii divide. In the present greatly stressed times, they invest people with resilience and hope. Such has been the reverence for them over the centuries that many Pakistanis are in denial about the culpability of TTP terrorists and seek refuge in far-fetched conspiracy theories. A deadly attack on a major shrine in 2005 signalled this new dimension of the terrorist’s war against Pakistan. Since then, some of the most revered shrines, where dedicated missionaries from the Arab-Islamic world with historical profiles, often very simple, sleep eternally, have been bombed. In killing people in these sanctuaries, the terrorist is not only shattering the devotees’ identities but uprooting the substratum of a 1,000-year-long history of what is today Pakistan. Destroying a shrine hallowed by time drives a deep hole in the cultural security of communities devoted to it.

Just as the Iraqis refused to be divided by this nefarious scheme and instead banded together to defeat Zarqawi and his militants to defend their own nation and culture, we must also not allow ourselves to fall prey to this same strategy of divide and conquer. Attacks against shrines and other cultural monuments are an attack on the very idea of Pakistan itself. We cannot stand by and allow this to happen.