“Something Went Wrong”: The Chilling Effect Of State Terrorism On Journalism

Something went wrong

When Najam Sethi discussed the assassination of Sabeen Mahmud on his show, an interesting thing happened. The audio feed cut in and out during the program. Many viewers ignored the brief periods of silence, chalking it up to technical problems with their sets or with the the transmission. Only later was it realised that the missing audio was probably not an accident.


Najam Sethi was literally “silenced” when he discussed the ISI. It should be noted that Sethi was not blaming or accusing ISI. He was merely talking about the agency. However even that was considered too dangerous.

It is unlikely that this censorship was done by ISI or any other national agency. Probably Geo News chose to self-censor – but that’s actually the point, isn’t it? Geo suffered a major smear campaign after airing accusations that ISI was involved in the attempted killing of Hamid Mir. After tendering a public apology to ISI, Jang group began publishing a string of ridiculously strong pieces praising Army chief Gen Raheel. Following Sabeen’s assassination, the media group was not going to make the same mistake again.

Geo isn’t the only media group to self-censor reporting about sensitive military institutions. Last year, Express Tribune told employees that they would no longer accept any opinion piece or cartoon on military or military operations. This was originally viewed as a response to terrorist attacks, but recent events indicate there is more too it.

Earlier today, Express Tribune published a piece originally from Reuters that quoted military officials telling that ISI chief Rizwan Akhtar is carrying out a “quiet, creeping takeover of Karachi by the military”.

The report was quickly deleted from Express Tribune’s website.

Express Tribune removes article about ISIThis is how terrorism works. There only need to be so many Saleem Shahzads, Umar Cheemas, and Hamid Mirs before the message is received loud and clear. After that, you don’t need to see the gun to know it’s there, and nobody has to censor you because you are more than willing to do it yourself.

Author: Omar Derawal

Latest articles

A Botched Arrest Embarrasses the Pakistani Establishment

On Monday October 19, Captain Safdar, the husband of PML-N vice President, Maryam Nawaz Sharif, was arrested from their hotel room in Karachi. What ensued...

Imran Khan Lies About Media Freedom Can’t Hide Ugly Reality of Repression

Pakistan ranks as one of the worst countries in the world when it comes to media freedom. According to global media watchdog, RSF (Reporters...

Pakistan: Graveyard for minorities

Pakistan may have been elected to the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) but it is fast becoming one of the most religious intolerant...

Imran Khan failing in dealing with his myriad challenges

Politics in Pakistan is a funny game. Neither brute majority in Parliament nor charisma offer manna for survival.  Only the ability to pocket pride...

Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Author: Omar Derawal